What’s the lure of organic?

New study claims organic food isn’t healthier than alternative

September 5, 2012
KEYWORDS organic
/ Print / Reprints /
/ Text Size+
crystal lindell
Crystal Lindell

The problem with organic food is that it doesn’t help you lose weight; it doesn’t support any farmers in South America; and now, it turns out, it isn’t even more nutritious than regular food.

A new study — published in the Annals of Internal Medicine — showed that organic food and non-organic food pretty much have the same levels of nutrients and contaminants, aside from a few exceptions. The risk for contamination with detectable pesticide residues was lower among organic than conventional produce (risk difference, 30% [CI, −37% to −23%]), but differences in risk for exceeding maximum allowed limits were small.

In addition, phosphorus levels were higher in organic food, but the difference was not clinically significant. And, antibiotic resistant bacteria tended to be higher in conventional chicken and pork.

But to sum up: Hey, sorry you just spent $100 more this week on groceries so you could eat organic peaches and organic chocolate. Turns out neither actually provides any more nutrients than the significantly cheaper regular peaches and regular chocolate.

The research is surely not the final word on the subject, but it’s a pretty big ding for “organic” nonetheless.

If everything in this research turns out to be true, the reasons to pay extra money for organic will have basically dwindled to: It’s good for the environment and pesticides might kill me in 70 years.

As someone on a budget, I have to say, I’m not buying it.

I mean, I wish I could shop the Whole Foods produce section every week, but I tried that once and went broke about four days in. Never mind the fact that organic candy bars tend to cost so much that you can’t even get change back from your five-dollar bill.

Now, I’m not saying I won’t pay extra money for food with a mission, it’s just that when I do I expect the price increase to be minimal and the impact to be tangible.

As in: “Yes, I will pay 30 cents more for a low-calorie, sugar-free gum that doesn’t leave an aftertaste.” Or, “Yes, this Fair Trade Chocolate bar is about $1 more than the other one at the register, but at least I know the people farming it are being given a fair wage.” Or even “Hey, this pasta is 80 cents more than the other one, but at least I’m getting all my fiber for the day.”

So I have a hard time saying to myself, “Wow, organic? Awesome. I’ll totally shell out $3 more for this candy bar because I know that the sugar used to make it was grown on soil 500 miles away that might be better off someday because of it.”

Soil. Really? We’re talking dirt. You’d like me to shell out more money so I can save some dirt?

Maybe I’m just too selfish to appreciate the significance, or maybe one day, when I have a child I’ll turn into one of those parents dead set against poisoning my kid’s body with anything that’s ever even seen a pesticide in the distance.

Or maybe, one day, I’ll be randomly wealthy and I’ll decide that the soil down south is more important to me than I once thought.

But as the world still struggles to get its groove back after the economic recession, I have a feeling helping to create good soil conditions on a distant farm somewhere will not be a top priority anytime soon for most people. Now excuse me while I buy 89-cent strawberries and a 79-cent candy bar at Aldi and then use the rest of my money to pay the rent. 

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to Candy Industry

Recent Articles by Crystal Lindell

You must login or register in order to post a comment.


September 6, 2012
And personally, the fact that you even wrote this without first checking the credentials of the agency doing the study is irresponsible, second it was not a study of organics vs conventional agriculture (they asked people questions and tabulated the results) and then common sense alone tells me if I have a choice between sitting down and eating a dozen or more toxic chemicals every day or eating my foods as close to clean as can be, I am going to choose the clean variety. I have no desire at all to change my diet to anything and everything I can purchase at the lawn and garden store. I am sorry but this piece is pure irresponsible journalism. It has already been proven that the major chemical producing companies in the US paid for this objectionable "study". Could you not have taken the time to find this out before publishing this piece? Many people struggle with their health daily because of the toxicity of our air, water, soil and thus our food. Reading a piece like this gives them no incentive to even check and find out if their problem just might be diminished by choosing a cleaner lifestyle. Sure, it's your choice if you choose to maintain the toxic levels surrounding you and your family's daily habits, but to try and push this off on someone else, that's just purely selfish.



Image Galleries

A Venetian Carnival, a Jelly Belly sculpture and gourmet chocolates! Oh my!

Candy Industry takes you into the French Pastry’s School For the Love of Chocolate event in Chicago, held Feb. 25.


Candy Industry Magazine

April 2014 Cover

April 2014

In this issue of Candy Industry, Editor Bernie Pacyniak reports on three candy manufacturers from his visit to Florida, hard candy is making a comeback, interpack, and more!
Table Of Contents Subscribe

Easter Sales

How do you expect Easter sales to be this year?
View Results Poll Archive

Candy Industry Store

M:\General Shared\__AEC Store Katie Z\AEC Store\Images\Candy Industry\natural-food-flavors-colora.gif
Natural Food Flavors and Colorants

Although many foods are appealing, and even perceived as natural, in spite of containing synthetic additives, consumer increasingly prefer food products which are fully natural.

More Products

Candy Industry's Kettle Awards

Kettle Awards

Since 1946, Candy Industry magazine has recognized leaders in the U.S. confectionery industry with the highest recognition possible, the Kettle Award. The distinguished recipients have captured this most coveted award by not only excelling within their companies, but by contributing to the greater good of the industry. It’s virtually a who’s who of past and present professionals who have left their mark as confectioners and business mavens. Learn more about the voting process as well as the annual Kettle Awards Ceremony by visiting our Kettle Awards Website

Clear Seas Research

Clear SeasWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications,Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.


fb40   twitter 40    youtube40    linked